Business | Market

UK Recruitment Industry 2023: Charting a Course Amidst Challenges

Discover the challenges and opportunities that lie ahead for recruitment businesses in these uncertain times.


As a partner at Recruitment Accountants and a trusted ally of APSCo, I am always immersed in the nuances and intricacies of the recruitment landscape. APSCo recently provided comprehensive insights and statistics from its member firms and other recruitment businesses. These metrics, when combined with Recruitment Accountants industry expertise, have painted a vivid picture of what 2023 holds for the UK recruitment sector. This blog aims to shed light on the prevailing challenges, and more crucially, chart a course for UK owner-managed recruitment businesses seeking to thrive in these uncertain times.

Setting the Economic Stage

The broader economic backdrop serves as the canvas upon which the recruitment picture is painted. The International Monetary Fund (IMF) prediction isn’t rosy, suggesting the UK might lag behind its G20 counterparts. A cocktail of high inflation, interest rates, and suboptimal trade performance seems to be the order of the day. With a projected 0.3% shrinkage in 2023 followed by a mere 1% growth in 2024, the economic climate remains challenging. Larger recruitment entities of which 69%, seem to be feeling this pinch more acutely, perhaps because they have already been worse hit by falling recruitment activity.

The UK’s decision to leave the EU continues to reverberate through the recruitment sector. Brexit has curtailed the influx of overseas talent, and in the eyes of many foreign workers, the UK’s reputation has taken a significant hit. One cannot downplay the influence of this geopolitical event in the current recruitment landscape. As 2023 unfolds with news of ongoing redundancies and shrinking workforces in various sectors, it’s evident that many businesses might temporarily freeze their recruitment drives.

Embracing Diversity & Inclusion

In recent years, the recruitment industry has witnessed a notable shift in priorities, with diversity & inclusion (D&I) becoming paramount. Many recruitment firms, regardless of their size or specialty, have recognised that fostering a diverse and inclusive workplace is not just a moral imperative, but also has clear business advantages.

As gatekeepers to job opportunities, recruitment firms find themselves in a unique position to influence change, not only within their internal operations but also in the broader employment landscape. It’s no longer just about filling positions; it’s about reshaping the very fabric of the workforce and fostering a culture where every individual has an equal opportunity to thrive. This proactive approach not only resonates with the values of today’s candidates but also positions recruitment agencies as trailblazers in championing a more inclusive future for all.

Sectoral Spotlight: Diverse Trends Across Industries

Diving deeper into the industry, sectoral trends offer both cautionary tales and beacons of opportunity:

Technology: Witnessing a jump from 36% to 55% within three years, it’s clear that the digital revolution is in full swing, with recruitment needs mirroring this trend.

Engineering & Technical: Accounting for 30% of recruitment activity, the continued fusion of innovation and its practical implementation remains a focal point.

Professional Services, Admin, HR & Finance: These areas continue to be popular and collectively represent more than a quarter of all recruitment endeavours.

Health & Social Care: Arguably the most critical yet challenging sector. A fusion of ever-growing demand juxtaposed against a talent shortfall exacerbated by Brexit ramifications makes this an area challenging but with potential for significant growth.

Confronting the Goliaths: The 2023 Challenges

In the grand tapestry of recruitment, several threads stand out, weaving challenges that agencies must contend with:

Shortage of Candidates: A staggering 85% of agencies pointed to the acute shortage of candidates. Talent pools have seen considerable contraction, primarily due to the decline in overseas staff as well as still feeling the impact of Covid with the available labour pools in some sectors.

Shortage of Consultants: About 73% of agencies surveyed mentioned the scarcity of consultants, underscoring a profound human resource challenge in the industry. This is most acute for firms with NFI of between £2m and £10m.

Retention Issues: Retaining top talent in recruitment has always been crucial. In these trying times, 41% find this one of their most pressing concerns. This is mainly for the larger firms with NFI of between £10m and £100m.

Adapting to a “normalised” market: Post-pandemic, many recruitment firms expanded rapidly, capitalising on the surge in demand. But as 2023 progresses, the recruitment landscape is stabilising. For firms that onboarded additional talent during this boom, there’s now a pressing challenge: assessing and potentially recalibrating headcount to align with the current market.

Charting the Path Forward: Recommendations for Resilience

With challenges come opportunities. Here are some actionable, practical steps that recruitment firms can embark on:

Forge Global Alliances: In an era where Brexit limits European opportunities, cast your net wider. Partnerships in other regions can mitigate local talent shortages.

Embrace Technological Innovation: Tools leveraging AI and machine learning can refine and streamline talent acquisition processes.

Empower through Education: Collaborate with educational entities to offer custom training programmes for your consultants as well as your candidates. Quite often in these challenging times businesses are looking to save on cost – training is not a cost to cut.

Assess ROI: Rather than going through your profit and loss cutting as many costs as possible, continually evaluate the returns on your business investments. Regularly scrutinise your overheads, ensuring that such outlays are in line with your strategic goals and bring tangible value to your enterprise.

Productisation: With a deep understanding of your clients’ concerns and their market landscape, and having built trust over time, it’s time to evolve. Consider crafting bespoke solutions/products that directly address their unique requirements. This could be in conjunction with another partner or expert in that particular field.

Expand Geographically: The sterling/dollar dynamics hint at opportunities across the Atlantic. Diversifying geographically can offset domestic uncertainties.

Specialise and Dominate: Establish expertise in niche sectors. Such focused efforts often yield richer dividends.

Reinvent Talent Retention Strategies: The modern workforce seeks growth, flexibility, and a sense of purpose. Align HR endeavours with these aspirations.

Diversify Service Offerings: Transition from being mere recruiters to holistic consultants, supporting end clients with their people strategy. Such an approach not only strengthens client relationships but also offers avenues for revenue diversification.

Stay Agile and Adaptive: The only constant is change. Ensure your business model remains agile, ready to pivot based on market needs. It’s good to have a 3 to 5 year business plan, but we recommend revisiting this on a very regular basis. The environment is changing rapidly and being able to review and reforecast on a regular basis will ensure your business can be agile and responsive to these changes.

Concluding Thoughts

The UK recruitment landscape of 2023, albeit challenging, is replete with opportunities. For businesses willing to adapt, innovate, and persevere, the rewards are manifold. Remember, success isn’t merely about navigating challenges; it’s about transforming them into opportunities. Armed with these insights and strategies, UK recruitment businesses stand poised to not only endure but also excel in the upcoming months.

Need business advice?

Ready to take your UK recruitment business to new heights? Call our friendly team on 0845 606 9632 or email to explore tailor-made strategies designed to elevate your business. Let’s fuel your success together!

Was this helpful?
share this
Sign up to receive our recruitment sector outlook
Includes hot topics, guest contributors & legislative updates
  • "*" indicates required fields

    This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
  • Contact us to get started

    Give us a call
    0845 606 9632
    Send us an email
    Stay Informed
    Sign up to receive the latest industry updates, events and publications.